BDK Heavy Duty Rubber Cargo Mat Liner - All-Weather Trunk Protection vs Motor Trend Rear Cargo Mat for SUV, heavy-duty trimmable liner
Overall winner: Motor Trend Rear Cargo Mat for SUV, heavy-duty trimmable liner
Key Differences
BDK's mat (A) is the more affordable option and offers a trim-to-fit design and elevated ridges for liquid control, making it better for customizable fits and general cargo protection. Motor Trend's FlexTough (B) is heavier-duty with no-slip grip on the bottom and ergonomic grooves for traction, and it has a higher average rating and more reviews, so pick B if you want a heavier construction and stronger user approval
BDK Heavy Duty Rubber Cargo Mat Liner - All-Weather Trunk Protection
All-weather cargo mat with trim-to-fit design for cars, SUVs, vans & trucks. Elevates durability with elevated ridges to trap liquids; easy to cut to size for a precise fit. Customers note good fit, durability, and value, with some reporting odor concerns
Pros
- trim-to-fit design for customized fit
- durable rubber polymer construction
- elevated ridges trap liquids
- flexible yet sturdy for heavy use
Cons
- some customers report larger-than-expected size
- mixed feedback on odor/smell
Motor Trend Rear Cargo Mat for SUV, heavy-duty trimmable liner
Heavy-duty, flexible cargo mat designed to guard against spills and debris with a no-slip bottom. Customers appreciate easy trimming and durability, though fit reliability varies
Pros
- heavy-duty rubber polymers
- no-slip grip on bottom
- ergonomic top ridges for traction
- protects against spills and debris
Cons
- fit may vary for some vehicles
- mixed feedback on odor
- trim accuracy can be challenging
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | BDK |
| Durability | Motor Trend |
| Versatility | BDK |
| User Reviews | Motor Trend |