Slim JIM rectangular trash can with venting channels (16 gal) vs Deskside Recycling Can, 7-gallon/28-quart, blue (pack of 4)
Key Differences
Choose the Rubbermaid 7-Gallon Deskside (A) if you need compact under-desk recycling containers and prefer a lower listed price and higher review count. Choose the Rubbermaid Slim Jim 16 Gal (B) if you need larger capacity and features that aid liner handling (venting channels and 4 bag cinches) and a rib-strengthened rim for crush resistance
Slim JIM rectangular trash can with venting channels (16 gal)
Rectangular trash can with venting channels for easy liner removal and secure bag cinches. Durable, rib-strengthened rim design reduces jamming when nested. Customer notes its slim design fits various spaces and handles weekly recyclables without spills
Pros
- venting channels aid liner removal
- 4 bag cinches for quick liner changes
- rib-strengthened rim resists crushing
- nested-friendly step design
Cons
- mixed value for money perception
Deskside Recycling Can, 7-gallon/28-quart, blue (pack of 4)
Durable plastic recycling bin for under-desk or under-sink use. Easy to clean with rolled rims. Customers note its roomy size and sturdy feel for bathrooms and offices
Pros
- durable plastic construction
- rolled rims for strength and easy cleaning
- fits under standard-height desks
- includes multiple color options
Cons
- packaging is four-count
- color availability implied but not specified for all spaces
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Rubbermaid Commercial Products |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Rubbermaid Commercial Products |
| User Reviews | Rubbermaid Commercial Products |