Magura 8.P disc brake pads (one size) vs Shimano J05a-Rf Resin Disc Brake Pad
Overall winner: Shimano J05a-Rf Resin Disc Brake Pad
Magura 8.P disc brake pads (one size)
Magura 8.P disc brake pads in aluminium. Easy to install with solid stopping power and low noise, though wear may be faster than expected
Pros
- strong stopping power
- easy to install
- low noise
- fits MT5 and Trail Sport 4 piston front brakes
Cons
- wear rate higher than expected
Shimano J05a-Rf Resin Disc Brake Pad
Resin disc brake pad with alloy radiator cooling fins for longer life and reduced fade. Low noise and good power modulation with aluminum backing; includes springs. Customers note solid Shimano OEM quality and easy installation, with mixed fit reported for 4-piston brakes
Pros
- low-noise resin pad
- excellent power modulation
- aluminum backing plate
- includes springs
Cons
- fit feedback mixed for 4-piston brakes
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | SHIMANO |
| Durability | SHIMANO |
| Versatility | Magura |
| User Reviews | Tie |