Foster's Pickled Asparagus Spears in a Jar, 16oz (3 Pack) vs Middleton's Pickled Asparagus Variety Pack (3 Jars)
Overall winner: Foster's Pickled Asparagus Spears in a Jar, 16oz (3 Pack)
Key Differences
Foster's (A) is a 3-pack of plain pickled asparagus with a lower listed price tier and higher average rating (4.70 from 484 reviews), while Middleton's (B) is a higher-priced 3-jar variety pack offering flavored options, American-made sourcing, and firmer texture with balanced tanginess. Choose Foster's if you want a more affordable, highly rated plain pickled asparagus option; choose Middleton's if you prefer multiple flavored jars, farm-direct freshness, and American-made product attributes
Foster's Pickled Asparagus Spears in a Jar, 16oz (3 Pack)
Traditional pickled asparagus spears in a jar, gluten-free, vegan-friendly, and low-calorie. Customers note firm texture and flavorful taste as a snack or platter garnish
Pros
- gluten-free
- vegan-friendly
- low calorie snack
- firm texture
Cons
- some size non-uniformity
- price considered high by some
Middleton's Pickled Asparagus Variety Pack (3 Jars)
Farm-to-table pickled asparagus spears in a 3-jar set (green, purple, and spicy). Fresh flavor with a tangy finish; praised for texture and versatility on salads
Pros
- set of 3 jar variety pack
- made in the USA
- firm texture
- tangy flavor
Cons
- some consider it pricey
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Foster's Since 1984 |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | MIDDLETON'S |
| User Reviews | Foster's Since 1984 |