Dog crate cover with Teflon protector for 36-inch crates vs MidWest dog crate cover with Teflon protector for 42-in crates, gray
Overall winner: MidWest dog crate cover with Teflon protector for 42-in crates, gray
Key Differences
Product A is a 36-inch cover that lists a lower price tier and fits most 36" crates; Product B is a 42-inch cover sized for most 42" crates (specifically designed for iCrate models 1542U and 1542DDU) and may be too spacious for smaller dogs. Both use Teflon fabric protectors and have nearly identical ratings, but B is aimed at larger crates while A is targeted at 36-inch models
Dog crate cover with Teflon protector for 36-inch crates
Privacy crate cover with Teflon fabric protector; resists stains and spills, designed for 36-inch crates. Customers note it is well-made, easy to assemble, and roomy for dogs up to 40 pounds
Pros
- Teflon fabric protector resists liquids and stains
- Designed to fit most 36-inch crates
- Privacy design with washable material
- Easy to assemble and disassemble
Cons
- Fits specific crate models only (iCrate 1536U/1536DDU and New World B36)
- May be spacious for dogs beyond 40 pounds
MidWest dog crate cover with Teflon protector for 42-in crates, gray
Poly-cotton crate cover with Teflon fabric protector that repels liquids and stains. Measures 42 x 28 x 30 inches, designed for 42-inch crates; helps reduce barking. Customers note easy assembly and roomy fit
Pros
- Teflon fabric protector resists stains and spills
- Designed to fit most 42-inch crates
- Easy to assemble and disassemble
- Roomy for dogs up to 40 pounds
Cons
- Some feedback on fit for multiple dogs varies
- Only compatible with specific crate models (iCrate 1542U | 1542DDU)
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | MidWest Homes for Pets |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | MidWest Homes for Pets |
| User Reviews | Tie |