Sharpie Cosmic Color 24-Count Permanent Markers Fine Point vs Madisi Washable Broad Line Markers, 240 Count, Assorted Colors
Overall winner: Sharpie Cosmic Color 24-Count Permanent Markers Fine Point
Key Differences
Sharpie Cosmic Color (A) is a permanent marker set with a 24-count and very high user rating (4.80 from 14,891 reviews) emphasizing vibrant, quick-drying, fade-resistant ink, while Madisi Washable (B) is a 240-count classroom-focused washable bulk pack that stresses durability when left uncapped and washable inks but has mixed feedback on color accuracy and fewer reviews (4.70 from 890). Choose Sharpie A if you want permanent, vibrant colors and stronger user approval; choose Madisi B if you need a large washable bulk supply for classrooms or groups
Sharpie Cosmic Color 24-Count Permanent Markers Fine Point
Permanent ink markers in vibrant cosmic colors for versatile surfaces. Quick-drying, fade- and water-resistant with AP certification. Customers value color variety and reliable performance across crafts, school projects, and coloring books
Pros
- vibrant color variety
- quick-drying, fade- and water-resistant ink
- works on paper, plastic, metal and more
- AP certified
Cons
- markers may dry out for some users
Madisi Washable Broad Line Markers, 240 Count, Assorted Colors
240 washable markers in 10 colors; classroom bulk pack with 24 markers per color. Durable and easy to clean, though color accuracy varies by user
Pros
- large color assortment
- washable markers
- durable for classroom use
- bulk pack suitable for groups
Cons
- mixed feedback on color accuracy
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Madisi |
| Durability | Sharpie |
| Versatility | Sharpie |
| User Reviews | Sharpie |