Rooftop cargo carrier, 18 cu ft hard shell vs DNA Motoring Roof Storage Box 12.7 cu ft
Overall winner: Rooftop cargo carrier, 18 cu ft hard shell
Key Differences
JEGS (Product A) offers a larger 18 cu ft weatherproof hard shell with four-corner locks and easy side access, and sits in a more affordable price tier; DNA MOTORING (Product B) is smaller at 12.7 cu ft, emphasizes easy installation, sturdy build and quiet operation but has fit variability and some reports of a brittle feel
Rooftop cargo carrier, 18 cu ft hard shell
Hard-shell rooftop cargo carrier with weatherproof seal and four-corner locking. Provides 18 cubic feet of interior space and easy loading from either side, no tools required. Customers note ease of installation and ample storage for camping gear
Pros
- weatherproof hard shell
- four-corner locking system
- easy side access loading
- no tools required
Cons
- mixed durability feedback
- some difficulty with locks
- top may detach under certain use
DNA Motoring Roof Storage Box 12.7 cu ft
Universal heavy-duty roof cargo carrier with 12.7 cu ft capacity and 110 lb load rating. Builds with impact-resistant ABS and side-opening design for easy access; some users report fit issues with certain vehicles
Pros
- easy to install
- sturdy build quality
- quiet operation
- large storage capacity
Cons
- fit may vary by vehicle
- some report brittle feel
- lock mechanism issues noted
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | JEGS |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | JEGS |
| User Reviews | JEGS |