Sawyer Permethrin Insect Repellent for Clothing & Gear vs Ranger Ready Repellents Picaridin 20% Tick & Insect Repellent, Night Sky Scent
Overall winner: Sawyer Permethrin Insect Repellent for Clothing & Gear
Key Differences
Choose Sawyer (A) if you want a permethrin fabric treatment that bonds to clothing, gear and tents for weeks and typically sits at a more affordable price point; it also has a higher aggregate rating. Choose Ranger Ready Picaridin (B) if you prefer a DEET-free, on-skin repellent offering timed protection claims (12 hours vs ticks/mosquitoes, 8 hours vs gnats/flies/chiggers) and a formulation designed for direct application to skin and clothing
Sawyer Permethrin Insect Repellent for Clothing & Gear
Permethrin spray bonds to fabric for up to 6 weeks or through 6 washings, without staining. Fragrance-free and works on clothing, fabrics, plastics, finished surfaces, and gear. Customer insight notes effectiveness against ticks and mosquitoes with positive longevity, though nozzle performance and odor receive mixed feedback
Pros
- bonds to fabric for extended protection
- fragrance-free formulation
- broad compatibility with fabrics and gear
- paired use with skin repellent for enhanced protection
Cons
- mixed feedback on nozzle performance
- mixed perception of odor
Ranger Ready Repellents Picaridin 20% Tick & Insect Repellent, Night Sky Scent
Picaridin 20% insect repellent for full-body use with 12-hour tick/mosquito protection and 8-hour protection for gnats, flies, and chiggers. Lavender- and lemon-scented, safe on gear, non-greasy and quick-acting. One customer noted strong effectiveness, while others mentioned pump issues
Pros
- 12 hours protection from ticks and mosquitos
- 8 hours protection for gnats, flies, chiggers
- non-greasy, quick-acting formula
- safe on gear
Cons
- pump mechanism reported to fail by some customers
- mixed feedback on skin irritation
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Sawyer |
| Durability | Sawyer |
| Versatility | Ranger Ready Repellents |
| User Reviews | Sawyer |