Johnny's Garlic Spread & Seasoning (18 oz, pack of 2) vs Garlic Garlic Seasoning, 4.5 oz (3-pack) by Tastefully Simple
Overall winner: Johnny's Garlic Spread & Seasoning (18 oz, pack of 2)
Key Differences
Johnny's (B07D9VZWFR) offers a lower listed price tier and larger unit size per pack (18 oz two-pack) with a strong garlic-parmesan flavor, while Tastefully Simple (B07DVRT4CW) is sold as smaller 4.5 oz jars in a three-pack, notes convenient granulated garlic but has reported seal integrity issues. Choose Johnny's if you want larger quantity and a parmesan-forward spread/seasoning; choose Tastefully Simple if you prefer a granulated spice-blend format despite a higher price tier and some packaging concerns
Johnny's Garlic Spread & Seasoning (18 oz, pack of 2)
Garlic parmesan spread with peppery seasonings. Adds flavor to pasta, potatoes, shrimp, and more. Customers highlight its versatility and easy sprinkle-on use
Pros
- versatile seasoning for multiple dishes
- easy-to-sprinkle format
- blend of parmesan, garlic, and spices
- good value for money
Cons
- contains parmesan cheese (allergen consideration)
Garlic Garlic Seasoning, 4.5 oz (3-pack) by Tastefully Simple
Garlic powder seasoning blend with minced garlic, onion, salt and spices. Adds flavor to meats, soups, and salads; versatile and easy to use. Customer note: flavorful with versatility, though some find it pricey
Pros
- flavorful garlic blend
- versatile seasoning for meats, soups, salads
- easy-to-use granulated form
- comes in multi-pack
Cons
- some customers find it pricey
- reports of seal integrity issues
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Johnny's |
| Durability | Tastefully Simple |
| Versatility | Tie |
| User Reviews | Johnny's |