Camerons Cedar Grilling Planks - 12 Pack (11.5" x 5.5") vs Wildwood Grilling Signature Cedar Planks 24-Pack (2 x 12) – USA Made
Overall winner: Wildwood Grilling Signature Cedar Planks 24-Pack (2 x 12) – USA Made
Key Differences
Wildwood Grilling offers a 24‑pack of USA-made cedar planks with a higher average rating (4.70 from 160 reviews) and is presented as a more affordable option, while Camerons is a 12‑pack with strong cedar flavor but more mixed feedback on plank size and thickness (4.40 from 789 reviews). Choose Wildwood if you want more planks, USA sourcing, and a higher-rated product; choose Camerons if you prefer a single-brand premium flavor experience and don’t need as many planks
Camerons Cedar Grilling Planks - 12 Pack (11.5" x 5.5")
Cedar grilling planks for smoky flavor, 12-pack. Soak before grilling and cook to baste in natural juices, enhancing salmon, fish, meat, and veggies. One customer notes they can accommodate two servings
Pros
- premium cedar flavor
- easy to use with soaking step
- 12-pack provides multiple uses
- allows food to roast slowly and baste in juices
Cons
- mixed opinions on size
- some consider thickness too thick or too thin
- flammability concerns reported by some customers
Wildwood Grilling Signature Cedar Planks 24-Pack (2 x 12) – USA Made
Cedar grilling planks from Western Red Cedar, made in the USA for salmon, fish, veggies, and fruit. Delivers gentle smoke and aroma; customers note good quality and value for money, especially for salmon
Pros
- USA-made and sourced
- food-safe facility
- includes 24 planks (2 packs of 12)
- delicate cedar aroma for grilling
Cons
- mixed durability feedback
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Wildwood Grilling |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Wildwood Grilling |
| User Reviews | Wildwood Grilling |