S-Union 4 Pack Electric Range Burner Elements (MP22YA/MP15YA/MP21YA) Replacement vs Porcelain burner drip pan & MP22YA element replacement set
Overall winner: Porcelain burner drip pan & MP22YA element replacement set
Key Differences
S-Union (Product A) is the more affordable 4-pack replacement set and is noted for quick heating and easy installation but has mixed fit reports and occasional bent units. AMI PARTS (Product B) is a higher-rated porcelain drip pan and MP22YA set that emphasizes fit for Whirlpool stoves and appearance improvements, though users report variable heat transfer and crooked drip pans
S-Union 4 Pack Electric Range Burner Elements (MP22YA/MP15YA/MP21YA) Replacement
S-Union replacement burner set for common electric ranges, includes 2x MP15YA 6" and 2x MP21YA 8" units. Customers note easy installation and quick heating, with some reports of fit issues and bentness
Pros
- easy to install
- heats quickly
- good quality for value
Cons
- fit may vary by stove
- some units sit crooked
- paint durability concerns
Porcelain burner drip pan & MP22YA element replacement set
Porcelain drip pans and burner element unit set for electric ranges. Easy to install, extends stove service life, with wear-, aging-, and corrosion-resistant properties. Looks improve old stoves; some users note heat transfer and crooked drip pans
Pros
- porcelain drip pans included
- easy to install
- wear and corrosion resistant
- extends range service life
Cons
- mixed heat transfer performance
- crooked drip pan reports
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | S-Union |
| Durability | AMI PARTS |
| Versatility | S-Union |
| User Reviews | S-Union |