HODAG Licking Stick Mock Scrape Kit for Deer Hunting vs Nationwide Scents Scrape Lure for Hunting
Overall winner: Nationwide Scents Scrape Lure for Hunting
Key Differences
Nationwide Scents (A) is a liquid buck scrape lure that mimics natural deer scent markers, is noted for working with scent drippers and drag applications, and has a higher review count and slightly higher average rating. HODAG (B) is a single-use licking stick mock scrape kit with a patented spring for longer activation and easy install, but reviewers report sturdiness issues and mixed functionality
HODAG Licking Stick Mock Scrape Kit for Deer Hunting
Mock scrape kit with AllSeason scent to attract whitetail deer. Easy setup and long-lasting attractant designed for limited applications. Customer feedback highlights mixed functionality and ease of installation
Pros
- Easy setup
- Long-lasting attractant with single use design
- Alternative to mineral blocks and feeders
- Enhances food plots
Cons
- Mixed feedback on effectiveness
- Sturdiness issues (leans over)
- Weak spring strength
Nationwide Scents Scrape Lure for Hunting
Deer lure that mimics natural scent markers to attract bucks. Useful for mock scrapes, scent drags, and wicks; designed for steady attraction in various seasons. Customers note effective deer activity and good scent quality
Pros
- mimics natural deer scent markers
- works with multiple applications (scrapes, drags, wicks)
- steady attraction across seasons
- positive customer-perceived quality and value
Cons
- mixed reviews on spray length
- mixed reviews on scrape effectiveness
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | NATIONWIDE SCENTS FRESH DEER URINE FROMOUR DEER TO YOUR DOOR |
| Durability | HODAG |
| Versatility | NATIONWIDE SCENTS FRESH DEER URINE FROMOUR DEER TO YOUR DOOR |
| User Reviews | NATIONWIDE SCENTS FRESH DEER URINE FROMOUR DEER TO YOUR DOOR |