Barnabas Gilding Kit with gold & silver leaf vs DecoArt Metallics Sterling Silver 3 Pack
Overall winner: DecoArt Metallics Sterling Silver 3 Pack
Key Differences
DecoArt’s Sterling Silver three-pack offers a higher average rating (4.60 vs 4.50) and is listed in a lower price tier, delivering a high-pigmentation metallic finish and reports of one-coat coverage; Barnabas Blattgold is a full gilding kit (leaves, adhesive, sealer) suited for traditional leaf application but has reported adhesion and sealability issues. Choose DecoArt if you want paint-like, consistent metallic coverage and a more affordable option; choose Barnabas Blattgold if you need a complete leaf gilding kit for beginner gilding techniques
Barnabas Gilding Kit with gold & silver leaf
Gilding kit with 100 sheets of imitation leaf, adhesive, sealer, gloves, brushes, and sanding supplies. Delivers easy application and adds dimension to art; customers praise adhesive quality and ease of use
Pros
- includes everything needed to start gilding
- easy to use with gilding adhesive
- color-changing blueish adhesive hue
- good adhesive quality praised by some customers
Cons
- adhesion can be mixed in experiences
- sealability issues reported (lid sealed shut)
- messiness and leakage reported
DecoArt Metallics Sterling Silver 3 Pack
Metallic paint set in sterling silver finish with rich color and high pigmentation. One reviewer notes a satin pearl-like sheen and full coverage with one coat, while others mention varying thickness
Pros
- high pigmentation
- rich metallic finish
- one-coat coverage (customer note)
- easy to use
Cons
- thickness varies by user
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | DecoArt |
| Durability | DecoArt |
| Versatility | DecoArt |
| User Reviews | DecoArt |