WORKDONE 2-Pack 3.5 inch Drive Caddy for PowerEdge vs Pack-4 3.5" hard drive tray caddy for Dell Poweredge

Overall winner: Pack-4 3.5" hard drive tray caddy for Dell Poweredge

Key Differences

Heretom's 4-pack offers a more affordable per-unit entry and higher average rating with claims of OEM-comparable build, making it better if you need multiple trays and broad Dell model fit. WORKDONE's 2-pack includes screws and specifies fit for 4.2-inch PowerEdge bays, so pick it if you need included hardware and that exact bay size

WORKDONE 2-Pack 3.5 inch Drive Caddy for PowerEdge

WORKDONE 2-Pack 3.5 inch Drive Caddy for PowerEdge

WORKDONE • ★ 3.9/5 • Budget

2-pack 3.5-inch drive caddies compatible with PowerEdge hot-swap bays. Includes screws and solid build quality for a secure fit. Customers note good compatibility with R640 and a precise fit

Pros

  • includes screws
  • solid build quality
  • good fit for PowerEdge 4.2-inch bays
  • two-pack value

Cons

  • compatibility limited to listed PowerEdge models
  • requires specific drive bay size
  • some models may vary by server type
Check current price on Amazon →
Pack-4 3.5" hard drive tray caddy for Dell Poweredge

Pack-4 3.5" hard drive tray caddy for Dell Poweredge

Heretom • ★ 4.0/5 • Budget

Caddy set for 3.5" SAS/SATA drives used in Dell PowerEdge rack servers. Provides fit and functional replacement with solid quality, comparable to OEM parts. Customer insight confirms perfect fit and reliable performance

Pros

  • fits 3.5" SAS/SATA drive bays
  • consistent fit for multiple Dell models
  • high-quality build comparable to OEM
  • includes multiple part numbers for compatibility

Cons

  • no explicit compatibility beyond listed models
  • no installation instructions provided
  • requires verification of server compatibility
Check current price on Amazon →

Head-to-Head

CriteriaWinner
Price Heretom
Durability Heretom
Versatility Heretom
User Reviews Heretom