Melis Original Monster Gluten Free Cookie Mix with M&M's vs Miss Jones Gluten-Free Monster Cookie Mix
Overall winner: Miss Jones Gluten-Free Monster Cookie Mix
Key Differences
Miss Jones (A) has a higher average rating (4.70 from 1,609 reviews) and is marketed as certified gluten-free with an oats-rich base; it comes in a 6-pack format. Meli's (B) is less expensive by tier, includes M&M-style milk chocolate candies in the mix, but has a lower rating (4.20 from 143 reviews) and mixed feedback on value
Melis Original Monster Gluten Free Cookie Mix with M&M's
Gluten-free cookie baking mix with natural chocolate chips and rolled oats. Great for chewy or slightly crisp cookies; includes chocolate bliss for chocolate lovers. Customers note tasty flavor and easy preparation
Pros
- gluten-free baking mix
- includes M&M's milk chocolate chips
- natural chocolate chips and rolled oats
- easy to bake chewy or slightly crispy cookies
Cons
- some customers consider it pricey
Miss Jones Gluten-Free Monster Cookie Mix
Gluten-free cookie mix made with oats and chocolate candies. Easy to bake with 1 egg and peanut butter. Customers note tasty flavor and good texture, with some reporting uneven bake results
Pros
- gluten-free and oat-based
- easy to bake with minimal ingredients
- positive texture and taste feedback
Cons
- some customers report it bakes unevenly
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Meli's |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Miss Jones Baking |
| User Reviews | Miss Jones Baking |