Magnetic key box for under-car storage vs Upgrade Extra Large Key Lock Box, Weatherproof Wall Mount

Overall winner: Magnetic key box for under-car storage

Key Differences

Fayleeko (A) is sold as a 2-pack and emphasizes large internal capacity (up to 10 keys) and easy wall mounting, making it better for stationary, shared-key storage. Gorilla Box (B) uses a strong magnet for under-car attachment and is designed to be waterproof/airtight, making it better for portable or vehicle-mounted concealment of keys and small extras

Magnetic key box for under-car storage

Magnetic key box for under-car storage

Gorilla Box • ★ 4.0/5 • Budget

Secure magnetic key box designed for under-car placement with strong magnets for secure attachment. Customers note sturdy construction and reliable magnet strength, though some report issues opening the box

Pros

  • strong magnet
  • sturdy construction
  • large enough for keys and extras
  • under-car placement design

Cons

  • mixed durability feedback
  • hinge closure issues
  • some users report it comes off
Check current price on Amazon →
Upgrade Extra Large Key Lock Box, Weatherproof Wall Mount

Upgrade Extra Large Key Lock Box, Weatherproof Wall Mount

Fayleeko • ★ 4.0/5 • Budget

Weatherproof key lock box with large interior space for up to 10 keys, including car keys, fobs, and cards. Praised for size, quality, and ease of use; some mixed feedback on the locking mechanism

Pros

  • large internal space for multiple keys
  • sturdy and quality construction
  • easy-to-mount design
  • versatile for car, house keys, and fobs

Cons

  • mixed reviews on lock functionality
Check current price on Amazon →

Head-to-Head

CriteriaWinner
Price Fayleeko
Durability Tie
Versatility Gorilla Box
User Reviews Tie