Treatlife smart ceiling fan switch, 4-speed, 2.4GHz wifi, neutral-wired vs Leviton Decora Smart Fan Speed Controller (2nd Gen) D24SF-1RW
Overall winner: Leviton Decora Smart Fan Speed Controller (2nd Gen) D24SF-1RW
Key Differences
TREATLIFE (A) offers a lower listed price, easy installation, 4-speed fan control and no hub required but needs a neutral wire and only supports single-pole. Leviton (B) is a higher-priced, brand-name Decora Smart unit with 4-speed control, Wi‑Fi scheduling and generally positive installs but several users report connectivity and dimming/brightness issues
Treatlife smart ceiling fan switch, 4-speed, 2.4GHz wifi, neutral-wired
Smart single-pole ceiling fan switch with 4 speed levels and wifi control. Works with voice assistants for hands-off control; requires neutral wire and 2.4GHz Wi-Fi. Customer note: easy install and seamless integration, though some report mixed speed control with voice commands
Pros
- 4 speed fan control
- 2.4GHz wifi connectivity
- voice assistant compatibility (Alexa/Google Home)
- neutral wire required
Cons
- only supports ceiling fans, no lighting control
- not compatible with 3-way circuits
- some users report speed control not working with voice command
Leviton Decora Smart Fan Speed Controller (2nd Gen) D24SF-1RW
Smart fan speed controller for ceiling fans with 4-speed options. Enables scheduling and voice control via compatible assistants. Users note easy installation and straightforward app, but some report connectivity issues
Pros
- 4-speed ceiling fan control
- scheduling capability
- easy installation
- straightforward app usage
Cons
- reports of connectivity issues
- some users experience WiFi connection failures
- dimming/brightness feature reports mixed
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | TREATLIFE |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Leviton |
| User Reviews | Leviton |