Purina Pro Plan Senior Wet Dog Food with Chicken & Rice Entree (12 x 13 oz cans) vs Nulo Small Breed Dog Signature Stew Chicken & Sweet Potato (Broth) - 24 x 2.8 oz Cup
Overall winner: Nulo Small Breed Dog Signature Stew Chicken & Sweet Potato (Broth) - 24 x 2.8 oz Cup
Key Differences
Purina Pro Plan (A) lists real chicken as the first ingredient and targets senior dogs with an optimal protein formula and no artificial colors/flavors/preservatives, and it typically sits at a more affordable price point. Nulo (B) emphasizes real shredded meat in broth, higher moisture and added omega fatty acids from coconut and salmon oil, and is portioned for small-breed mealtimes but is positioned in a higher price tier
Purina Pro Plan Senior Wet Dog Food with Chicken & Rice Entree (12 x 13 oz cans)
Wet dog food for senior dogs 7+ with real chicken as first ingredient and complete nutrition. Supports immune system, skin and coat, with 23 vitamins and minerals; no artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives. Customers note good taste and some digestive benefits
Pros
- real chicken first ingredient
- optimum protein for senior dogs
- nourishes skin and coat
- no artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives
Cons
- mixed reviews on water content
- some consider it expensive
Nulo Small Breed Dog Signature Stew Chicken & Sweet Potato (Broth) - 24 x 2.8 oz Cup
Protein-rich wet dog food with real shredded meat in a flavorful broth. Supports hydration at mealtime and provides essential nutrients for small breeds. Customer note: pleasant smell and visible meat chunks in gravy
Pros
- protein-rich with real shredded meat
- high-moisture, supports hydration
- essential nutrients for small breed dogs
- omega fatty acids from coconut and salmon oil
Cons
- size suitability varies by dog
- perceived price/value varies
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Purina Pro Plan |
| Durability | Nulo |
| Versatility | Purina Pro Plan |
| User Reviews | Tie |