Razer Phantom Keycap Upgrade Set vs YMDK Dolch 122 PBT keycap set with shine-through rainbow
Overall winner: Razer Phantom Keycap Upgrade Set
Key Differences
Razer (A) targets RGB-focused users with translucent pudding sides and legendless tops for a minimalist look plus bottom-lasered legends; it also has a lower listed price and higher average rating. YMDK (B) offers solid PBT construction with shine-through rainbow legends and a distinctive Dolch/rainbow carbon sunset aesthetic but can look brown under white LEDs and has a slightly lower rating
Razer Phantom Keycap Upgrade Set
Unique pudding keycaps with stealth tops and translucentsides for RGB effect; bottom-lasered legends. Customers note quality, tactile feel, and mixed lighting/color brightness
Pros
- stealth, legendless tops for minimalist look
- translucent sides enhance RGB visibility
- bottom-lasered legends for durability
- includes keycap removal tools & stabilizers
Cons
- mixed reviews on brightness and color accuracy
- mixed keyboard fit with certain keyboards
YMDK Dolch 122 PBT keycap set with shine-through rainbow
PBT double-shot shine-through keycaps in a rainbow carbon sunset design for MX switches. Provides solid construction and visible shine-through with backlighting. Some users report fit alignment differences
Pros
- solid construction
- shine-through visibility
- rainbow carbon sunset design
- compatible with most standard MX layouts
Cons
- color may appear brown with white LEDs
- fit may vary on some keyboards
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Razer |
| Durability | YMDK |
| Versatility | Razer |
| User Reviews | Razer |