Sylvania LED A19 12W 1100L, frosted, 75W replacement (24 pack) vs ST58 Antique LED Filament Light Bulbs, 4W E26 Dimmable 2700K Warm Amber (Pack of 12)
Overall winner: ST58 Antique LED Filament Light Bulbs, 4W E26 Dimmable 2700K Warm Amber (Pack of 12)
Key Differences
LEDVANCE A (B09SS9946W) delivers higher brightness at 1100 lumens and a lower listed price tier, while ASOKO B (B0CZ6ZL21F) emphasizes vintage amber-glass styling, smooth dimming 10%–100% and higher CRI for eye-friendly light. Choose A if you need brighter, more affordable 75W-equivalent A19 LEDs; choose B if you want decorative Edison-style filament bulbs with smooth dimming and warmer 2700K tone
Sylvania LED A19 12W 1100L, frosted, 75W replacement (24 pack)
LEDVANCE Sylvania A19 LED bulbs replace 75W incandescent with 12W, 1100 lumens, soft white at 3500K. Long-lasting up to 11,000 hours with energy savings; some customers note flickering and mixed longevity
Pros
- energy-efficient replacement for 75-watt bulbs
- bright output 1100 lumens
- long lifespan up to 11,000 hours
- soft white 3500K color
Cons
- mixed longevity reports
- some users experience flickering
ST58 Antique LED Filament Light Bulbs, 4W E26 Dimmable 2700K Warm Amber (Pack of 12)
LED filament bulbs with smooth dimming from 10% to 100% and amber glass for warm Edison-style lighting. High color rendering and eye-friendly design with no flicker. Customers note vintage look and good dimming performance
Pros
- smooth dimming without flicker
- high color rendering index
- vintage Edison-style appearance
- cool to the touch
Cons
- may require compatible dimmers
- amber glass aesthetic may affect light tone
- depends on dimmer performance
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | LEDVANCE |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | ASOKO |
| User Reviews | LEDVANCE |