Perry's Almost Black Water Lily – Bare Root Perennial vs Barbara Dobbins Live Perennial Water Lily – Pre Grown Bare Root
Overall winner: Barbara Dobbins Live Perennial Water Lily – Pre Grown Bare Root
Key Differences
Perry's Almost Black (A) is noted for dramatic dark-center blooms and is sold as a bare root ready to plant with a note that it can grow larger than typical lily pads. Barbara Dobbins (B) offers peach-pink 4–8" blooms, olive-green pads with maroon flecks and is described as pre-grown bare root that aids natural water filtration; it also specifies the included leaves/buds may vary
Perry's Almost Black Water Lily – Bare Root Perennial
Dark-centered water lily with burgundy blooms and dark green pads. Ready-to-plant bare root perennial for outdoor ponds. Customer notes show easy planting and lasting vigor
Pros
- dramatic dark-center blooms
- winter hardy perennial
- bare root and ready to plant
- easy-care and beginner-friendly
Cons
- color description may vary by light
- grows larger than typical lily pads over time
Barbara Dobbins Live Perennial Water Lily – Pre Grown Bare Root
Water lily with peach-pink blooms and round olive-green pads. Provides natural filtration for ponds; ships with several leaves and flower buds. Customer note: plants arrive in good condition and grow well over years
Pros
- peach-pink blooms 4-8 wide
- round olive-green pads with maroon flecks
- natural filtration for water
Cons
- requires pond or container setup
- includes several leaves and buds but may vary by plant
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Tie |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Chalily |
| User Reviews | Tie |