Grease Tray with Catch Pan for Dyna Glo/Nexgrill/etc (30"-36") vs Matchwaves 100 pack grease cup liners for Blackstone griddles
Overall winner: Matchwaves 100 pack grease cup liners for Blackstone griddles
Key Differences
Matchwaves A is a pack of recyclable heavy‑duty aluminum grease cup liners designed for Blackstone-style griddles and emphasizes disposability and easy cleanup, while CaptainGrill B is an adjustable-length (30–36 in) stainless-steel grease tray/catch pan intended for Dyna Glo and similar grills offering a longer-lasting physical tray. Choose A if you want disposable liners for griddle grease cups and a more affordable option; choose B if you need an adjustable, reusable catch pan for larger grill setups and greater long-term robustness
Grease Tray with Catch Pan for Dyna Glo/Nexgrill/etc (30"-36")
Adjustable stainless steel drip pan for gas grills, fits multiple brands with 30–36" length and 15.5" depth. Customers note easy assembly and a sturdy, quality replacement that fits well with their grills
Pros
- adjustable length 30-36 inches
- stainless steel construction
- easy to assemble
- fits multiple grill models
Cons
- corrosion potential over time
Matchwaves 100 pack grease cup liners for Blackstone griddles
Disposable aluminum liners for grease cups on Blackstone griddles; keeps griddle clean and minimizes mess. Customers report easy use and effective grease containment
Pros
- Compatible with Blackstone 28 inch and 36 inch griddles
- Heavy-duty, food-grade aluminum foil
- Leak-resistant, disposable grease liners
- Multipurpose: can store food or bake
Cons
- May require slight bending for fit on some models
- Not compatible with earlier 28-inch/36-inch versions with different cup sizes
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Matchwaves |
| Durability | CaptainGrill |
| Versatility | Matchwaves |
| User Reviews | Matchwaves |