New Construction Mounting Plate for LED Recessed Lights (3/4/6 in) with Extendable Hanger Bars vs ASD 18 in. New Construction Mounting Plate (6 Pack)
Overall winner: New Construction Mounting Plate for LED Recessed Lights (3/4/6 in) with Extendable Hanger Bars
Key Differences
Product A (ASD) is positioned as a more affordable option with universal compatibility for 8/10/12 in housings and alignment notches for multi-plate setups. Product B (ASD Lighting Corp) targets flexibility for 3/4/6 in LEDs with extendable hanger bars to 25 inches and sliding clips for secure positioning, making it better when planning to support multiple small LED sizes and longer spans
New Construction Mounting Plate for LED Recessed Lights (3/4/6 in) with Extendable Hanger Bars
Adjustable mounting plate for LED recessed lighting installs in new or remodeled spaces. Features extendable 14" hanger bars up to 25" and sliding clips for secure positioning. One customer notes good performance in heavy rain, reflecting product quality
Pros
- adjustable for 3" | 4" | 6" LED lights
- extendable hanger bars to 25 inches
- sliding clips with nails for secure positioning
- easy installation process
Cons
- mixed installation experience in some cases
- durability opinions vary between sturdy and flimsy
ASD 18 in. New Construction Mounting Plate (6 Pack)
Universal flat mounting plate with an asymmetric round hole for 8, 10, and 12 in. LED recessed lights. Quick install with alignment notches for multiple plates. Customers note easy installation and good quality, with some fit concerns for 6 in. lights
Pros
- universal 8"/10"/12" light compatibility
- alignment notches for multi-plate layout
- quick installation with screws or nails
- durable flat mounting plate design
Cons
- some customers report it doesn't fit 6" lights
- mixed views on sturdiness
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | ASD |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | ASD Lighting Corp |
| User Reviews | Tie |