Old Potters wildlife in-shell peanuts for birds and squirrels vs Wagner's Nyjer & Black Oil Sunflower Seed Bird Food Bundle
Overall winner: Old Potters wildlife in-shell peanuts for birds and squirrels
Key Differences
Wagner's bundle (A) combines nyjer and black-oil sunflower seeds praised for finches and high energy, and is listed in a more affordable price tier; Old Potters (B) offers USA-grown, Non-GMO in-shell peanuts favored for squirrel/bird nutrition and reports stronger durability but mixed comments on unbroken peanuts. Choose Wagner's if you want a finch-friendly seed mix and lower price tier; choose Old Potters if you prioritize USA-grown, Non-GMO in-shell peanuts and slightly higher durability feedback
Old Potters wildlife in-shell peanuts for birds and squirrels
In-shell peanuts grown in the USA, non-GMO, for wildlife. Supports local farms and provides nutrition for birds and squirrels. Customer noted large size and freshness
Pros
- usa-grown small-farm peanuts
- non-gmo assurance
- in-shell for wildlife-friendly feeding
- fresh and clean product
Cons
- durability varies according to customer reports
- mixed experiences with peanut integrity
Wagner's Nyjer & Black Oil Sunflower Seed Bird Food Bundle
Nyjer seed for finches and thin-shelled sunflower seeds fuel a wide range of backyard birds. Customers note good freshness and value, with some mixed reviews on bag durability and seed containment
Pros
- finch-friendly nyjer seed
- thin-shelled sunflower seeds attract many birds
- refill-friendly, resealable bag in some reviews
- high energy content for birds
Cons
- mixed feedback on bag durability
- some reports of seeds spilling
- disagreement on whether birds eat the seed
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Wagner's |
| Durability | Old Potters |
| Versatility | Wagner's |
| User Reviews | Old Potters |