W11188040 upper glass shelf for Whirlpool refrigerators vs 2 Pack Refrigerator Door Bin Replacement for Frigidaire
Overall winner: 2 Pack Refrigerator Door Bin Replacement for Frigidaire
Key Differences
AMI PARTS 2-pack is a plastic refrigerator door bin designed for storage with a lower listed price and higher review volume; it’s limited by a 15.38" length and fits specific models. FBULWSEC’s W11188040 is a single 3mm 9H tempered glass shelf, food-grade certified and marketed as a direct replacement for multiple Whirlpool parts but has reports of sizing larger than originals
W11188040 upper glass shelf for Whirlpool refrigerators
Glass shelf for upper refrigerator compartment. 3mm tempered, food-grade material; direct replacement for multiple part numbers. Customers note fit in RV fridges and tempered quality; some say size varies
Pros
- 9H tempered glass
- 3mm thick for durability
- food-grade certified material
- direct replacement for multiple parts
Cons
- size may differ from original shelves
- mixed feedback on capacity
- compatibility depends on model
2 Pack Refrigerator Door Bin Replacement for Frigidaire
2-pack door bin replacement for Frigidaire fridges. Fits top 2 shelves with length 15.38 inches; designed for durability and easy installation. Customers note they hold bottles and jars and are sturdy
Pros
- fits top 2 shelves
- durable construction
- easy installation
- adequate storage capacity
Cons
- not compatible with certain part numbers
- specific length and fit may limit compatibility
- no OEM part guarantee mentioned
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | AMI PARTS |
| Durability | FBULWSEC |
| Versatility | AMI PARTS |
| User Reviews | AMI PARTS |