Planters Deluxe Unsalted Mixed Nuts (4-pack) 15.25 oz vs Oven Roasted Never Fried Mixed Nuts (2x24oz) with Peanuts
Overall winner: Planters Deluxe Unsalted Mixed Nuts (4-pack) 15.25 oz
Key Differences
Planters (A) is a 15.25 oz canister sold as a 4-pack with a higher average rating and notes about long-lasting freshness and being unsalted; Fisher (B) is sold as a larger 24 oz canister (2-pack) that is oven-roasted with sea salt and advertises no added oils or artificial ingredients. Choose Planters if you prioritize a higher-rated, unsalted option and freshness; choose Fisher if you want oven-roasted nuts with sea salt and a larger per-pack size
Planters Deluxe Unsalted Mixed Nuts (4-pack) 15.25 oz
Mixed nuts assortment featuring roasted peanuts, almonds, cashews, Brazil nuts, and pecans. Provides protein and variety with notable freshness and balanced salt content. Customers note good taste, quality, and value
Pros
- variety of nut types
- notable freshness that lasts
- balanced salt content
- per-pack info clearly stated
Cons
- almond content receives mixed reviews
- some say too many almonds
Oven Roasted Never Fried Mixed Nuts (2x24oz) with Peanuts
Mixed nuts including peanuts, almonds, cashews, pistachios, pecans, baked and seasoned with sea salt. One customer notes they’re baked rather than fried, adding to flavor depth
Pros
- oven roasted preparation
- includes multiple nut varieties
- sea salt seasoning
- no added oils
Cons
- some customers find almond content too high
- mixed feedback on salt level
- tastes can be perceived as very flavorful or horrible
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Fisher |
| Durability | PLANTERS |
| Versatility | Tie |
| User Reviews | PLANTERS |