Best Penne Pasta Under $200 (2026)
We ranked items under $200 by a composite value score combining nutritional metrics (protein, fiber, net carbs), ingredient quality, average consumer rating, and price-per-ounce
Top Picks
-
1
Barilla Protein+ Cellentani Pasta (14.5 oz) – plant-based lentil, chickpea & pea
Plant-based protein pasta with lentil flour in a Cellentani shape. Provides plant protein and fiber; customers note good taste and quality alongside nutrition benefits
- 17g protein per serving from lentil flour
- plant-based, vegan and non-GMO
- cellentani pasta shape for variety
-
2
Barilla Mini Wheels Pasta, 16 oz Box (Pack of 12) - Non-GMO
Mini wheels pasta from Barilla made with durum wheat semolina for al dente texture. Great for pasta salads and kid-friendly meals; customers highlight quality, taste, and value
- mini wheels shape for kid appeal
- made with durum wheat semolina
- pack of 12 x 16 oz boxes
-
3
Fiber Gourmet light penne pasta, low carb & high fiber (8 oz, pack of 6)
Fiber Gourmet penne pasta with low carb and high fiber advantages. Flavorful, with similar texture to regular pasta; features 18 g fiber per serving and low calorie count. Customer note highlights taste and fiber benefits
- high fiber content
- low carb formulation
- non-GMO, kosher certified
-
4
Pastabilities zoo animal pasta - fun shapes (4 pack, 14 oz) natural wheat
Fun shaped pasta for kids featuring zoo animals; made from 100% durum wheat with vegetable powders for bite-sized pieces. Customers praise taste and cuteness, noting kid-friendly shapes
- 100% durum wheat pasta
- fun zoo animal shapes
- all-natural and kosher certified
-
5
Fiber Gourmet low net carb elbow macaroni pasta
Low net carb elbow pasta with high fiber and reduced calories, supporting fullness and digestion. Customers note good taste, texture, and health benefits
- 24g fiber per serving
- 17g net carbs per serving
- 48% fewer calories than regular noodles
-
6
Pastabilities Princess Pasta Crown Castle Fun Shapes (4 Pack, 14 oz)
Kid-friendly pasta with princess- and castle-shaped shapes. Made from 100% durum wheat with vegetable powders for bite-size pieces; bronze-dyed, slow-dried for porous texture. All-natural, non-GMO, and USA-made
- fun princess shapes
- porous texture for better sauce absorption
- 100% durum wheat, non-GMO
-
7
Pastabilities Star of David pasta (4 pack, 14 oz)
Star of David shaped pasta made from 100% durum wheat with vegetable powders; porous, bronze-dried texture. Great for kids and themed meals; customers praise taste and fun shapes
- fun star shapes for kids
- ancient-style bronze-dyed pasta
- certified kosher, non-GMO
-
8
Pastabilities Fun Shaped Pasta for Kids Horsin' Around
Fun-shaped pasta for kids featuring horse and horseshoe shapes. Made with 100% durum wheat and vegetable powders for a porous texture. A customer notes it’s great for gifts and party themes
- kid-friendly shapes
- high-quality ingredients
- made in the USA
-
9
Barilla Pastina Pasta 12 oz boxes (pack of 16)
Barilla Pastina pasta made with 100% durum wheat for al dente texture. Quick-cooking mini pasta, popular in soups; families report kids enjoy it and it pairs well with comforting meals
- mini pasta form
- durum wheat nutrition
- ready in minutes
-
10
Pastabilities Fun Shaped Pasta for Kids - Good Luck Pasta (4 Pack, 14 Oz)
Fun shaped pasta with shamrocks for St Patrick's Day, made from 100% durum wheat and vegetable powders. All-natural, Non-GMO, and made in the USA. Customers note delicious taste and adorable shapes, though shape retention varies
- kid-friendly shamrock shapes
- 100% durum wheat with vegetable powders
- bronze-die, slow-dried texture